Less than full size mill suggestions
-
- Posts: 118
- Joined: Mon Dec 07, 2020 6:14 am
- Location: Panama City, FL
Less than full size mill suggestions
I recently picked up a 60's era South Bend 10" lathe in my quest to replace the 3-in-1 I've been using. The difference is night and day!
Now it's time to tackle the mill side. I'm finding lots of full size knee mills around here (mostly Bridgeports) but unfortunately, there is no way I'm fitting one of those in my shop. I saw a mention of the Burke MV1 and that looks like I could squeeze one in. But even if I expanded my search area significantly (even beyond an 8 hour drive), I just don't see any of those available.
Like I was with the lathe, I'm not opposed to new. Precision Matthews seems to be well thought of. Maybe something like a 728 or 932.
Any other suggestions for a small floor standing or a large benchtop mill?
Now it's time to tackle the mill side. I'm finding lots of full size knee mills around here (mostly Bridgeports) but unfortunately, there is no way I'm fitting one of those in my shop. I saw a mention of the Burke MV1 and that looks like I could squeeze one in. But even if I expanded my search area significantly (even beyond an 8 hour drive), I just don't see any of those available.
Like I was with the lathe, I'm not opposed to new. Precision Matthews seems to be well thought of. Maybe something like a 728 or 932.
Any other suggestions for a small floor standing or a large benchtop mill?
Re: Less than full size mill suggestions
First, you should add your location to your profile, so people know where you are.
We have what looks to be a nice, compact Sheldon horizontal mill for sale here, but I don't know if you are anywhere near here.
As to mills with a smaller footprint, the Clausing and Rockwell machines are nice machines in a small footprint. They are both available as horizontal and vertical. What you will find is that they cost more than some Bridgeports, for exactly the issue you mentioned - hobby guys can get them in their basement when a Bridgeport won't fit.
Horizontal mills are less popular and can go for less, as people would rather have a vertical, but as Jim Rozen says, they are easy to work with - you just have to change your thinking 90 degrees.
Pratt & Whitney made a small benchtop horizontal / vertical mill, but it's nowhere near the work envelope of the Clausing / Rockwell machines.
Be sure that whatever you look at has cranks and dials for all three directions - there are mills called "hand mills" that have levers and they are meant for production work.
BTW, a benchtop actually takes up MORE space than a small floorstanding mill - the tables I have used for my P&W mill ranged from 2'x2' to 2'x3', both of which are larger than the footprint of a Clausing or Rockwell mill.
Steve
We have what looks to be a nice, compact Sheldon horizontal mill for sale here, but I don't know if you are anywhere near here.
As to mills with a smaller footprint, the Clausing and Rockwell machines are nice machines in a small footprint. They are both available as horizontal and vertical. What you will find is that they cost more than some Bridgeports, for exactly the issue you mentioned - hobby guys can get them in their basement when a Bridgeport won't fit.
Horizontal mills are less popular and can go for less, as people would rather have a vertical, but as Jim Rozen says, they are easy to work with - you just have to change your thinking 90 degrees.
Pratt & Whitney made a small benchtop horizontal / vertical mill, but it's nowhere near the work envelope of the Clausing / Rockwell machines.
Be sure that whatever you look at has cranks and dials for all three directions - there are mills called "hand mills" that have levers and they are meant for production work.
BTW, a benchtop actually takes up MORE space than a small floorstanding mill - the tables I have used for my P&W mill ranged from 2'x2' to 2'x3', both of which are larger than the footprint of a Clausing or Rockwell mill.
Steve
-
- Posts: 118
- Joined: Mon Dec 07, 2020 6:14 am
- Location: Panama City, FL
Re: Less than full size mill suggestions
Profile updated. In the Florida Panhandle. Used to be outside of Chicago (Barrington, to be exact). I see lots of equipment for sale up there.
I've never even seen a horizontal mill in person. The idea of an end mill horizontal with the end pointing at you seems... weird.
I've never even seen a horizontal mill in person. The idea of an end mill horizontal with the end pointing at you seems... weird.
- Bill Shields
- Posts: 10460
- Joined: Fri Dec 21, 2007 4:57 am
- Location: 39.367, -75.765
- Contact:
Re: Less than full size mill suggestions
Ah yes...but the chips all fall to the floor..
Granted -> they can be annoying to set up when the tool is horizontal and gravity not working with you to hold things to the table until clamped>
I have a half size Bridgeport clone on a stand and except for table travel allowances and height considerations it does use as much space as a full size unit
...but then I have 9' ceilings in my basement and the wells index slid right in with lots of vertical clearance.
No matter what recommend you avoid round column mills that lose alignment.
In general something that looks like a Bridgeport only smaller is the general direction to go.
Granted -> they can be annoying to set up when the tool is horizontal and gravity not working with you to hold things to the table until clamped>
I have a half size Bridgeport clone on a stand and except for table travel allowances and height considerations it does use as much space as a full size unit
...but then I have 9' ceilings in my basement and the wells index slid right in with lots of vertical clearance.
No matter what recommend you avoid round column mills that lose alignment.
In general something that looks like a Bridgeport only smaller is the general direction to go.
Too many things going on to bother listing them.
-
- Posts: 118
- Joined: Mon Dec 07, 2020 6:14 am
- Location: Panama City, FL
Re: Less than full size mill suggestions
Been searching for a Burke MV1, Deckel FP1, Maho, Clausing 8520 or 8530 and a Hardinge TM/UM.
Danged things are like unicorns.
Danged things are like unicorns.
- Bill Shields
- Posts: 10460
- Joined: Fri Dec 21, 2007 4:57 am
- Location: 39.367, -75.765
- Contact:
Re: Less than full size mill suggestions
Deckels are very good mills...but can hardly be considered less than full size..and they are unicorns... anyone that has one only parts with it by way of his widow..
Too many things going on to bother listing them.
-
- Posts: 118
- Joined: Mon Dec 07, 2020 6:14 am
- Location: Panama City, FL
Re: Less than full size mill suggestions
Anyone got an idea what this is? I thought it might be a Hardinge. It's close but not quite a match.
Re: Less than full size mill suggestions
It looks like a miniature version of an Abene with the head that rotates for both vertical and horizontal.VelocityDuck wrote: ↑Tue Apr 19, 2022 10:31 am Anyone got an idea what this is? I thought it might be a Hardinge. It's close but not quite a match.
The picture here is resized so I can't zoom in without it getting fuzzy.
If you have an original higher-resolution pic, zoom in and see if you can read any of the lettering on the side.
Steve
-
- Posts: 118
- Joined: Mon Dec 07, 2020 6:14 am
- Location: Panama City, FL
Re: Less than full size mill suggestions
That's the only picture on the ad. Unfortunately, the seller is not responding.
Re: Less than full size mill suggestions
In 2019 HGR in Cleveland had 4 of these benchtop Optimil BF Vario 46 Mills for sale at very reasonable prices. Chinese made but by a German company. If memory serves they were CNC as well as manual. Wish I had room for one. https://www.machinetools.com/en/models/ ... f-46-vario
--earlgo
Here is the link to the Optimil BF Vario 46. --earlgo
Before you do anything, you must do something else first. - Washington's principle.
Re: Less than full size mill suggestions
Looks like a Van Norman.VelocityDuck wrote:Anyone got an idea what this is? I thought it might be a Hardinge. It's close but not quite a match.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
- Bill Shields
- Posts: 10460
- Joined: Fri Dec 21, 2007 4:57 am
- Location: 39.367, -75.765
- Contact:
Re: Less than full size mill suggestions
Careful of the optimil variants...more than a few problems with the spindle speed controller.
IIRC it is not just a straightforward VFD swap..had an odd motor.
The Precision Matthews machines come from China
IIRC it is not just a straightforward VFD swap..had an odd motor.
The Precision Matthews machines come from China
Too many things going on to bother listing them.